Pre-order for GenCon with code GenCon. We will be closed from 7/31-8/4. Orders will be fulfilled upon our return. 3 dozen ship for free!

Butterfinger Blondies - Critical Hit Cookies

Butterfinger Blondies

Regular price
Sale price
Unit price
Shipping calculated at checkout.

For our Butterfinger Blondies, we took our base blondie with its rich flavors of brown sugar and browned butter and loaded it with Butterfingers and milk chocolate chips.  The unique crispy, peanut butter taste of the Butterfingers combines with the milk chocolate chips to recreate the experience of eating the candy but it's made even better when combined with the blondie flavor.  You'll find the blondies are just as addicting as the candy.  Is this the flavor you've been searching for?  Try and find out!


Contains nuts

Customer Reviews

Based on 4 reviews
Jackie Heimkes

Butterfinger Blondies

Kyle Ashcraft
First Time Blondie Eater

Never had a Blondie before and this was a great first experience and love these.

Adam Mulder
So good!

I love these blondies. Rich, sweet, and delicious! They hit the spot every time.

Timothy Coffelt
Best Cookies!!

I am convinced that this amazing baker rolled 20s on all their baking checks. Best cookies!! Made playing our sessions so much fun! Nothing like cookies and pathfinder!