We will be away from December 2-4. Orders will be fulfilled upon our return. Orders over 3 dozen ship for free!

Fly Free or Pie Cookie - Critical Hit Cookies

Fly Free or Pie Cookie

Regular price
Sale price
Unit price
Shipping calculated at checkout.

The Fly Free or Pie cookie was inspired by Starfinder's Fly Free or Die Adventure Path.  While it's an obvious play on words, the rags to riches to ruin to revenge leads pcs on a roller coaster ride.  What better grounding could they have to keep them going than a homey apple pie cookie.  With a rich buttery cinnamon cookie loaded with flavorful chunks of dried apples and honey Teddy Grahams, our Fly Free or Pie cookie is comforting and delicious.  Plus it is satisfying enough to keep you going through your biggest adventures.

Customer Reviews

Based on 7 reviews
Jarred Bournigal
Just enough apple

It's like a snickerdoodle with just enough apple to keep up some intrigue.

I had to stop myself from eating 2 more.

Kendra Speedling

I ordered a few varieties of cookie to try, and I had to get this one to snack on during our Fly Free or Die game! They're really soft and the apple cinnamon flavor is great.

Hive Queen
Great Customer Service

I ordered these cookies as a gift for a friend who needed a pick me up. Communication was excellent and helpful, and super friendly. Will definitely be buying cookies from them again.

Alexander Kamensky

Fly Free or Pie Cookie

Rob Trimarco
My favorite cookie!

An amazing combination of flavors on this thiccc with three C's cookie. The perfect blend of appley, honeyish, and cinnamonny goodness. Definitely buying these on the regular.