Pre-order for GenCon with code GenCon. We will be closed from 7/31-8/4. Orders will be fulfilled upon our return. 3 dozen ship for free!

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies - Critical Hit Cookies

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies

Regular price
Sale price
Unit price
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Our oatmeal chocolate chip cookies are just like Grandma used to make, provided Grandma was a chocoholic.  Crammed full of oats and dark chocolate with a touch of cinnamon, they are a hearty cookie which pleases kids and adults alike.  In fact, they have remained the favorite of both a niece and nephew as they continued to grow up.  See if they will become your favorite!


Customer Reviews

Based on 8 reviews
Cherilyn Booze

These cookies are amazing!!

k cheung
Cancels out bad luck

When I’m beset with bad luck, eating one of these cookies has instantly reversed my fortunes. Lost keys were quickly found, red lights turned green, the cats stopped scratching the couch, even the tv commercials became more interesting. I think I’ll buy another batch and then buy a lottery ticket.

Awesome Cookies!!!

There are great tasting! I am still eating them!!!
Thank you!!!

Angel Espinoza
One of my top three favs

I love oatmeal cookies. I love Critical Hit cookies. No surprise, this was another natural 20 on the ol' baking skill check. If you haven't tried one (or several dozen) yet, I recommend you take a bite. It's magical how soft they keep even after a few days. Yum!

Joseph Naftali
So damn good

Seriously, I keep buying these to share with friends and eat far more than I should BEFORE I share with friends. Delicious.